You WOULD substitute a jacket for a scarf... Totally not the same. But I agree, I'm digging the Club Monoco Fall style. LOVE the trench coat (which is something I recently got though in black). Now that summer has come, I'm waiting for it to be gone so I can get on with my favorite season!
I'm definitely agreeing that fall is my favorite season as well! And, of course, you know that I LOVE trenches. =)